Are Manual Transmissions an Endangered Species?
Several months ago, I have the opportunity to drive a new Audi A3 equipped with Volkswagen Auto Group's revolutionary Direct Shift Gearbox (DSG). Sweet Jesus, was it neat. Pull the trigger paddle on the wheel and the damned thing ripped off a perfectly timed, very fast, and appropriately firm shift. I think I drive stick pretty well ...but not this well. As an added bonus, when I hit some traffic, I slid it into the 'Automatic' program and it behaved pretty much like a regular old automatic transmission.For the sake of simplicity, the DSG operates like a stick shift, but with a computer system running the clutch pedal - resulting in perfrctly timed shifts. Nothing new you say? Your Chrysler Sebring has that (they call it 'autostick')? Not quite. Many automatic transmissions offer 'manual' control over shifts, and the uninitiated will likely not understand the difference between those and the DSG (or similar systems). Those transmissions are still, at their heart, an automatic transmission, torque converter and all. Still confused? Most of the people I try to explain it to are, which leads me to believe that I am not making a lick of sense or they are busy staring at my unruly nose hair. Robert Farago, from 'The Truth About Cars', wrote up a little article that does a great job of explaining. Robert Farago, incidently, writes pretty good editorials - although I still can't figure out what his ideal car is considering he usually can come up with lots of negatives on any car reviewed. None the less, The Truth About Cars is a great read and I highly reccomend it.
Do I think that this new breed of transmission will render the classic manual transmission obsolete? Yes, I do believe it - but not anytime soon. There is still something magical about being able to perfectly manipulate a manual gearbox through the gate. The DSG has little to be sorry for, though - and, as someone who deals with Washington D.C. traffic, I would be thankful for the availability of an automatic mode every once in a while too.



